Multiomic prediction of therapeutic targets for human diseases associated with protein phase separation.

The phenomenon of protein phase separation (PPS) underlies a wide range of cellular functions. Correspondingly, the dysregulation of the PPS process has been associated with numerous human diseases. To enable therapeutic interventions based on the regulation of this association, possible targets should be identified. For this purpose, we present an approach that combines the multiomic PandaOmics platform with the FuzDrop method to identify PPS-prone disease-associated proteins. Using this approach, we prioritize candidates with high PandaOmics and FuzDrop scores using a profiling method that accounts for a wide range of parameters relevant for disease mechanism and pharmacological intervention. We validate the differential phase separation behaviors of three predicted Alzheimer's disease targets (MARCKS, CAMKK2, and p62) in two cell models of this disease. Overall, the approach that we present generates a list of possible therapeutic targets for human diseases associated with the dysregulation of the PPS process.

Towards sequence-based principles for protein phase separation predictions.

The phenomenon of protein phase separation, which underlies the formation of biomolecular condensates, has been associated with numerous cellular functions. Recent studies indicate that the amino acid sequences of most proteins may harbour not only the code for folding into the native state but also for condensing into the liquid-like droplet state and the solid-like amyloid state. Here we review the current understanding of the principles for sequence-based methods for predicting the propensity of proteins for phase separation. A guiding concept is that entropic contributions are generally more important to stabilise the droplet state than they are for the native and amyloid states. Although estimating these entropic contributions has proven difficult, we describe some progress that has been recently made in this direction. To conclude, we discuss the challenges ahead to extend sequence-based prediction methods of protein phase separation to include quantitative in vivo characterisations of this process.

FuzPred: a web server for the sequence-based prediction of the context-dependent binding modes of proteins.

Proteins form complex interactions in the cellular environment to carry out their functions. They exhibit a wide range of binding modes depending on the cellular conditions, which result in a variety of ordered or disordered assemblies. To help rationalise the binding behavior of proteins, the FuzPred server predicts their sequence-based binding modes without specifying their binding partners. The binding mode defines whether the bound state is formed through a disorder-to-order transition resulting in a well-defined conformation, or through a disorder-to-disorder transition where the binding partners remain conformationally heterogeneous. To account for the context-dependent nature of the binding modes, the FuzPred method also estimates the multiplicity of binding modes, the likelihood of sampling multiple binding modes. Protein regions with a high multiplicity of binding modes may serve as regulatory sites or hot-spots for structural transitions in the assembly. To facilitate the interpretation of the predictions, protein regions with different interaction behaviors can be visualised on protein structures generated by AlphaFold. The FuzPred web server (https://fuzpred.bio.unipd.it) thus offers insights into the structural and dynamical changes of proteins upon interactions and contributes to development of structure-function relationships under a variety of cellular conditions.

Alternatively spliced exon regulates context-dependent MEF2D higher-order assembly during myogenesis.

During muscle cell differentiation, the alternatively spliced, acidic ß-domain potentiates transcription of Myocyte-specific Enhancer Factor 2 (Mef2D). Sequence analysis by the FuzDrop method indicates that the ß-domain can serve as an interaction element for Mef2D higher-order assembly. In accord, we observed Mef2D mobile nuclear condensates in C2C12 cells, similar to those formed through liquid-liquid phase separation. In addition, we found Mef2D solid-like aggregates in the cytosol, the presence of which correlated with higher transcriptional activity. In parallel, we observed a progress in the early phase of myotube development, and higher MyoD and desmin expression. In accord with our predictions, the formation of aggregates was promoted by rigid ß-domain variants, as well as by a disordered ß-domain variant, capable of switching between liquid-like and solid-like higher-order states. Along these lines, NMR and molecular dynamics simulations corroborated that the ß-domain can sample both ordered and disordered interactions leading to compact and extended conformations. These results suggest that ß-domain fine-tunes Mef2D higher-order assembly to the cellular context, which provides a platform for myogenic regulatory factors and the transcriptional apparatus during the developmental process.

Protein interactions: anything new?

How do proteins interact in the cellular environment? Which interactions stabilize liquid-liquid phase separated condensates? Are the concepts, which have been developed for specific protein complexes also applicable to higher-order assemblies? Recent discoveries prompt for a universal framework for protein interactions, which can be applied across the scales of protein communities. Here, we discuss how our views on protein interactions have evolved from rigid structures to conformational ensembles of proteins and discuss the open problems, in particular related to biomolecular condensates. Protein interactions have evolved to follow changes in the cellular environment, which manifests in multiple modes of interactions between the same partners. Such cellular context-dependence requires multiplicity of binding modes (MBM) by sampling multiple minima of the interaction energy landscape. We demonstrate that the energy landscape framework of protein folding can be applied to explain this phenomenon, opening a perspective toward a physics-based, universal model for cellular protein behaviors.

Sequence-based Prediction of the Cellular Toxicity Associated with Amyloid Aggregation within Protein Condensates.

Various neurological dysfunctions are associated with cytotoxic amyloid-containing aggregates formed through the irreversible maturation of protein condensates generated by phase separation. Here, we investigate the amino acid code for this cytotoxicity using TDP-43 deep-sequencing data. Within the droplet landscape framework, we analyze the impact of mutations in the amyloid core, aggregation hot-spot, and droplet-promoting residues on TDP-43 cytotoxicity. Our analysis suggests that TDP-43 mutations associated with low cytotoxicity moderately decrease the probability of droplet formation while increasing the probability of multimodal binding. These mutations promote both ordered and disordered binding modes, thus facilitating the conversion between the droplet and amyloid states. Based on this understanding, we develop an extension of the FuzDrop method for the sequence-based prediction of the cytotoxicity of aging condensates and test it over 20,000 TDP-43 variants. Our analysis provides insight into the amino acid code that regulates the cytotoxicity associated with the maturation of liquid-like condensates into amyloid-containing aggregates, suggesting that, at least in the case of TDP-43, mutations that promote aggregation tend to decrease cytotoxicity, while those that promote droplet formation tend to increase cytotoxicity.

Protein condensation diseases: therapeutic opportunities.

Condensed states of proteins, including liquid-like membraneless organelles and solid-like aggregates, contribute in fundamental ways to the organisation and function of the cell. Perturbations of these states can lead to a variety of diseases through mechanisms that we are now beginning to understand. We define protein condensation diseases as conditions caused by the disruption of the normal behaviour of the condensed states of proteins. We analyze the problem of the identification of targets for pharmacological interventions for these diseases and explore opportunities for the regulation of the formation and organisation of aberrant condensed states of proteins.

Are casein micelles extracellular condensates formed by liquid-liquid phase separation?

Casein micelles are extracellular polydisperse assemblies of unstructured casein proteins. Caseins are the major component of milk. Within casein micelles, casein molecules are stabilised by binding to calcium phosphate nanoclusters and, by acting as molecular chaperones, through multivalent interactions. In the light of such interactions, we discuss whether casein micelles can be considered as extracellular condensates formed by liquid-liquid phase separation. We analyse the sequence, structure and interactions of caseins in comparison with proteins forming intracellular condensates. Furthermore, we review the similarities between caseins and small heat-shock proteins whose chaperone activity is linked to phase separation of proteins. By bringing these observations together, we describe a regulatory mechanism for protein condensates, as exemplified by casein micelles.

FuzDrop on AlphaFold: visualizing the sequence-dependent propensity of liquid-liquid phase separation and aggregation of proteins.

Many proteins perform their functions within membraneless organelles, where they form a liquid-like condensed state, also known as droplet state. The FuzDrop method predicts the probability of spontaneous liquid-liquid phase separation of proteins and provides a sequence-based score to identify the regions that promote this process. Furthermore, the FuzDrop method estimates the propensity of conversion of proteins to the amyloid state, and identifies aggregation hot-spots, which can drive the irreversible maturation of the liquid-like droplet state. These predictions can also identify mutations that can induce formation of amyloid aggregates, including those implicated in human diseases. To facilitate the interpretation of the predictions, the droplet-promoting and aggregation-promoting regions can be visualized on protein structures generated by AlphaFold. The FuzDrop server (https://fuzdrop.bio.unipd.it) thus offers insights into the complex behavior of proteins in their condensed states and facilitates the understanding of the functional relationships of proteins.

Proteome-wide landscape of solubility limits in a bacterial cell.

Proteins are prone to aggregate when expressed above their solubility limits. Aggregation may occur rapidly, potentially as early as proteins emerge from the ribosome, or slowly, following synthesis. However, in vivo data on aggregation rates are scarce. Here, we classified the Escherichia coli proteome into rapidly and slowly aggregating proteins using an in vivo image-based screen coupled with machine learning. We find that the majority (70%) of cytosolic proteins that become insoluble upon overexpression have relatively low rates of aggregation and are unlikely to aggregate co-translationally. Remarkably, such proteins exhibit higher folding rates compared to rapidly aggregating proteins, potentially implying that they aggregate after reaching their folded states. Furthermore, we find that a substantial fraction (~ 35%) of the proteome remain soluble at concentrations much higher than those found naturally, indicating a large margin of safety to tolerate gene expression changes. We show that high disorder content and low surface stickiness are major determinants of high solubility and are favored in abundant bacterial proteins. Overall, our study provides a global view of aggregation rates and hence solubility limits of proteins in a bacterial cell.

Adventures on the Routes of Protein Evolution-In Memoriam Dan Salah Tawfik (1955-2021).

Understanding how proteins evolved not only resolves mysteries of the past, but also helps address challenges of the future, particularly those relating to the design and engineering of new protein functions. Here we review the work of Dan S. Tawfik, one of the pioneers of this area, highlighting his seminal contributions in diverse fields such as protein design, high throughput screening, protein stability, fundamental enzyme-catalyzed reactions and promiscuity, that underpin biology and the origins of life. We discuss the influence of his work on how our models of enzyme and protein function have developed and how the main driving forces of molecular evolution were elucidated. The discovery of the rugged routes of evolution has enabled many practical applications, some which are now widely used.

Molecular Determinants of Selectivity in Disordered Complexes May Shed Light on Specificity in Protein Condensates.

Biomolecular condensates challenge the classical concepts of molecular recognition. The variable composition and heterogeneous conformations of liquid-like protein droplets are bottlenecks for high-resolution structural studies. To obtain atomistic insights into the organization of these assemblies, here we have characterized the conformational ensembles of specific disordered complexes, including those of droplet-driving proteins. First, we found that these specific complexes exhibit a high degree of conformational heterogeneity. Second, we found that residues forming contacts at the interface also sample many conformations. Third, we found that different patterns of contacting residues form the specific interface. In addition, we observed a wide range of sequence motifs mediating disordered interactions, including charged, hydrophobic and polar contacts. These results demonstrate that selective recognition can be realized by variable patterns of weakly defined interaction motifs in many different binding configurations. We propose that these principles also play roles in determining the selectivity of biomolecular condensates.

FuzDB: a new phase in understanding fuzzy interactions.

Fuzzy interactions are specific, variable contacts between proteins and other biomolecules (proteins, DNA, RNA, small molecules) formed in accord to the cellular context. Fuzzy interactions have recently been demonstrated to regulate biomolecular condensates generated by liquid-liquid phase separation. The FuzDB v4.0 database (https://fuzdb.org) assembles experimentally identified examples of fuzzy interactions, where disordered regions mediate functionally important, context-dependent contacts between the partners in stoichiometric and higher-order assemblies. The new version of FuzDB establishes cross-links with databases on structure (PDB, BMRB, PED), function (ELM, UniProt) and biomolecular condensates (PhaSepDB, PhaSePro, LLPSDB). FuzDB v4.0 is a source to decipher molecular basis of complex cellular interaction behaviors, including those in protein droplets.

Sequence Determinants of the Aggregation of Proteins Within Condensates Generated by Liquid-liquid Phase Separation.

The transition between the native and amyloid states of proteins can proceed via a deposition pathway via oligomeric intermediates or via a condensation pathway involving liquid droplet intermediates generated through liquid-liquid phase separation. While several computational methods are available to perform sequence-based predictions of the propensity of proteins to aggregate via the deposition pathway, much less is known about the physico-chemical principles that underlie aggregation within condensates. Here we investigate the sequence determinants of aggregation via the condensation pathway, and identify three relevant features: droplet-promoting propensity, aggregation-promoting propensity and multimodal interactions quantified by the binding mode entropy. By using this approach, we show that it is possible to predict aggregation-promoting mutations in droplet-forming proteins associated with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). This analysis provides insights into the amino acid code for the conversion of proteins between liquid-like and solid-like condensates.

Generic nature of the condensed states of proteins.

Proteins undergoing liquid-liquid phase separation are being discovered at an increasing rate. Since at the high concentrations present in the cell most proteins would be expected to form a liquid condensed state, this state should be considered to be a fundamental state of proteins along with the native state and the amyloid state. Here we discuss the generic nature of the liquid-like and solid-like condensed states, and describe a wide variety of biological functions conferred by these condensed states.

Frustration in Fuzzy Protein Complexes Leads to Interaction Versatility.

Disordered proteins frequently serve as interaction hubs involving a constrained variety of partners. Complexes with different partners frequently exhibit distinct binding modes, involving regions that remain disordered in the bound state. While the conformational properties of disordered proteins are well-characterized in their free states, less is known about the molecular mechanisms by which specificity can be achieved not with one but with multiple partners. Using the energy landscape theory concept of protein frustration, we demonstrate that complexes of disordered proteins exhibit a high degree of local frustration, especically at the binding interface. These suboptimal interactions lead to the possibility of multiple bound substates, each displaying distinct frustration patterns, which are differently populated in complexes with different partners. These results explain how specificity of disordered proteins can be achieved without a single common bound conformation and how the confliict between different interactions can be used to control the binding to multiple partners.

Fuzziness and Frustration in the Energy Landscape of Protein Folding, Function, and Assembly.

Are all protein interactions fully optimized? Do suboptimal interactions compromise specificity? What is the functional impact of frustration? Why does evolution not optimize some contacts? Proteins and their complexes are best described as ensembles of states populating an energy landscape. These ensembles vary in breadth from narrow ensembles clustered around a single average X-ray structure to broader ensembles encompassing a few different functional "taxonomic" states on to near continua of rapidly interconverting conformations, which are called "fuzzy" or even "intrinsically disordered". Here we aim to provide a comprehensive framework for confronting the structural and dynamical continuum of protein assemblies by combining the concepts of energetic frustration and interaction fuzziness. The diversity of the protein structural ensemble arises from the frustrated conflicts between the interactions that create the energy landscape. When frustration is minimal after folding, it results in a narrow ensemble, but residual frustrated interactions result in fuzzy ensembles, and this fuzziness allows a versatile repertoire of biological interactions. Here we discuss how fuzziness and frustration play off each other as proteins fold and assemble, viewing their significance from energetic, functional, and evolutionary perspectives.We demonstrate, in particular, that the common physical origin of both concepts is related to the ruggedness of the energy landscapes, intramolecular in the case of frustration and intermolecular in the case of fuzziness. Within this framework, we show that alternative sets of suboptimal contacts may encode specificity without achieving a single structural optimum. Thus, we demonstrate that structured complexes may not be optimized, and energetic frustration is realized via different sets of contacts leading to multiplicity of specific complexes. Furthermore, we propose that these suboptimal, frustrated, or fuzzy interactions are under evolutionary selection and expand the biological repertoire by providing a multiplicity of biological activities. In accord, we show that non-native interactions in folding or interaction landscapes can cooperate to generate diverse functional states, which are essential to facilitate adaptation to different cellular conditions. Thus, we propose that not fully optimized structures may actually be beneficial for biological activities of proteins via an alternative set of suboptimal interactions. The importance of such variability has not been recognized across different areas of biology.This account provides a modern view on folding, function, and assembly across the protein universe. The physical framework presented here is applicable to the structure and dynamics continuum of proteins and opens up new perspectives for drug design involving not fully structured, highly dynamic protein assemblies.